
This post will contain spoilers for Breaking Dawn and The Host. If you haven’t read the book, best you leave now.
****Spoilers Below*********
I’m not happy about this book. I read it last week and decided to give myself a few days to cool off and see if my initial response was too emotional. Instead, the more I think about it, the more frustrated I get.
First and foremost, this is supposed to be a YA book. Sex and vioIence are indeed found within the YA genre, but marriage and motherhood? OK, I can even buy that, but how about at least some sort of character growth that involves pain and consequences for the average 12-18 year old reader. I really don’t care if a book aims to send a particular message to a reader. Reading is fun, and honestly, if I wanted deeper meaning in my reading content, I wouldn’t be reading much fiction at all. My question, or concern rather, regarding this book is, is it trying to send the message it actually conveys?
I guess the moral dilema of having your teenage character having sex is apparently solved by having her get married first. What? I guess life is pretty easy for teenage wives, let’s go ahead and add a little motherhood to the mix. Oh and BTW, if you think you aren’t pretty enough, fast enough, smart enough…. let’s just become immortal too and improve your looks. They wern’t good enough when you were mortal. Now you are beautiful, sans depth, but beautiful.
The cost of immortality? Losing your family and becoming a bloodlusting lunatic. I could live with that. I was looking forward to that. Oh, but I forgot, this is Bella we’re talking about. For some reason, there are no consequences to her actions. She miraculously bypasses all the horrors that new vampires are subject to, and did I mention she gets to keep her family in the picture too….. they understand. How nice.
Oh and let us not forget poor Jacob. How oh how are we gonna fix this poor boy’s broken heart? Since he can’t have Bella, let’s imprint him on Bella’s child. Bella no longer has to feel pain and regret over not loving Jacob because once he see’s Nessie (oh, please)….. Problem fixed.
But this is a book about vampires, so let’s get the bad guys in there for the big battle. Let’s rally the troops and take a stand against the evil Volturi. Tense, ready and waiting, finally some action…………
Oops, on second thought, let’s resolve this peacefully by ripping off the ending of The Host. Everyone go home now, it was a false alarm.
And all you other members of the Cullen clan: Carlisle, Esme, Rosalie, Emmet, Jasper and Alice…. you aren’t important enough to have more than a few lines in this novel.
The best characters were the two Romanian vampires, Vladimir and Stefan. Too bad they couldn’t get their own book.
Hey, I’m a fan. I really enjoyed the other 3 books in the series… I loved The Host too. I think Mrs. Meyer is a great writer that can craft a story… I just don’t think she had the guts to do what needed to be done with this book. I’d prefer a little angst and perhaps even a death. Most of all, I would have preferred a heroine.